This is one of those plant questions that seems contradictory until you understand what's actually happening. Snake plants (Sansevieria, or Dracaena trifasciata if you prefer the reclassified name) are famously drought tolerant. Overwater them in soil and they rot. Yet you can root a cutting in a glass of water and it will happily grow. How does that make sense?
The answer is oxygen.
What roots actually need
Roots don't just absorb water and nutrients. They breathe. Like every living tissue in a plant, roots need oxygen for respiration, the process that generates the energy to grow, absorb nutrients and keep cells working. Cut off the oxygen supply and root cells start to die.
This is why waterlogged soil is lethal. The problem isn't the water itself. It's that water has pushed out the air. Healthy soil is roughly a quarter air by volume, and those air pockets are what make oxygen available to roots. When soil stays saturated, those pockets fill with water and the oxygen disappears. Roots suffocate.
It gets worse. Soggy, oxygen-starved soil is perfect for the rot organisms that thrive in those conditions. They're responsible for the soft, brown, foul-smelling rot that kills overwatered succulents. The rot isn't caused by water directly. It's caused by what water does to the soil environment.
Why soil structure matters
Fresh potting mix has texture: coarse particles, organic matter, perlite or sand creating spaces between the components. Water flows through, drains, and leaves those air pockets intact.
Over time, soil breaks down. Organic matter decomposes, particles compact, and the mix loses its structure. What was once well-draining becomes dense and fine, holding water far longer than it should. The same watering schedule that worked when the plant was first potted becomes dangerous a year or two later.
This is why repotting matters. Not just because roots need more room, but because fresh mix restores the air space roots depend on.
So why does water propagation work?
Water contains dissolved oxygen, absorbed from the air at its surface. The concentration is low compared to the air in good soil, but it's enough for a cutting that doesn't yet have the demands of a full root system.
More importantly, there's no soil to compact and no dense, degraded medium trapping stagnant moisture against the tissue. When you change the water regularly, you're not just keeping it fresh. You're topping up the oxygen.
The roots that form in water are also different from soil roots. They're often more fragile and less branched. This is why plants rooted in water can struggle when moved to soil: they need time to grow roots suited to life in a solid medium.
What this means for how you care for plants
Water less than you think you need to. Let soil dry out between waterings, not just at the surface but through the pot. Lift the pot: if it feels light, water. If it still feels heavy, wait.
Refresh the soil every two to three years, even if the plant doesn't look rootbound. Fresh soil isn't a luxury. It's infrastructure.
And if you're seeing rot, the instinct to water more carefully next time is right, but check the soil too. Compacted, broken-down mix will rot roots no matter how careful you are.
Keep reading: what desert plants do in the dark and bringing tropicals in before the first frost.